Blog of the International Sociological Association (ISA)

Police States and Academic Freedom

January 28, 2010 77 Comments

By Ujjwal Kumar Singh and Nandini Sundar, University of Delhi 

As social scientists, our research involves field interactions with people, sometimes in conflict situations. Given the importance of relevance and timeliness in our respective disciplines – sociology and political science – we often study issues which deal with politics, and from perspectives which may not be agreeable to the authorities. At all times, however, we strive for objectivity and independence in our research. It can be no-one’s case that such research  should not be done in the social sciences, and that only security think tanks and journalists should have access to conflict areas. Genuine research cannot come out of being embedded with any side. Indeed, the government must positively welcome such independent research by social scientists, because it can provide an alternative view to what is available from other sources.

However, despite the government’s new emphasis on higher education and ‘world class research’ it remains confined to a security mindset, where only certain types of  people can do research and only on certain subjects, or from perspectives the government approves of. National security and national honour are routinely invoked to stymie the most harmless work, especially when it comes to hapless foreign scholars. Coomi Kapoor recently reported in the Indian Express, (20 December 2009) that ‘a Chinese student who applied to do his PhD in a university in Delhi on caste and class in Malgudi, R K Narayan’s fictionalised village, was turned down on the grounds that there is no caste system in India ever since reservations were introduced.’ But even those who don’t require visas are hemmed in by people who lack the most basic understanding of what research is all about.  One of us was present at a meeting to discuss research proposals on access to justice in India. Scholars from a reputed law university wanted to compare the ‘people’s courts’ run by Naxalites, the instant justice dispensed by dacoits in the Chambal area, and the regular judicial system, to understand why so many people were turning to the former two arenas. One would have thought this was a matter of great interest not just to the scholarly community but to the public at large and to the judiciary. Yet, the official from the Law Ministry who was present there to ‘advise’ came down hard on the proposal on the grounds that it would legitimize the Naxalites and the Chambal dacoits. Since when has studying something become a way of legitimizing it?

In the last week of December 2009, the Chhattisgarh government took this police mentality to an extreme, by escorting us out of the state. Under the pretext of giving us ‘security’, the Chhatisgarh police effectively had us in their custody for a night and a day. We had decided to use the university winter break to visit Dantewada.  Nandini was doing follow-up research on the impact of the current conflict situation on people’s everyday lives, including evaluating the status of livelihoods for her case before the Supreme Court on Salwa Judum. Ujjwal was doing preliminary research on the civil liberties and law in Dantewada. Both are perfectly legitimate academic and social activities, and indeed, restrictions on the free movement of a witness or complainant before the Court amounts to actionable contempt of court.

We had planned to stay for five days to talk to people and collect material. However, in both Dantewada and Sukma, the police put pressure on lodge owners to deny us accommodation. We were detained in Sukma for checking in the evening of the 30th with no explanation for why they had stopped us, and no questions as to why we were there.  At midnight on the 30th, 6-7 armed SPOs burst into our room at the college hostel where we had taken refuge. The next morning we were followed by seven armed SPOs with AK 47s from Sukma in an unmarked white car, and this was replaced at Tongpal by twelve SPOs in two jeeps. None of them had any name plates.  The SPOs also scared our jeep drivers by taking photos of them and the vehicle. The SPOs followed us one pace behind even into tourist spots in Bastar and shops in Jagdalpur, intimidating all those around us as well, and preventing us from talking to people freely. DGP Vishwaranjan claimed on the phone that it was for our ‘protection’ that we were given this treatment since there was news of Naxalite troop movement, and has gone on to say (Indian Express, 3rd Jan), “anything can happen. Maoists can attack the activists to put the blame on the police. We will deploy a few companies of security forces for the security of the activists.”  The claims by the DGP are absurd considering that that the police were relentlessly ensuring that we got no accommodation anywhere and were evidently compelling us to leave Sukma for Jagdalpur in the middle of the night. The SP of Dantewada, Amaresh Misra, was somewhat more honest when he said he had instructions from above to ‘escort’ out ‘visiting dignitaries.’ The SPOs in their jeeps followed us some way from Jagdalpur to Raipur, even when we were on the bus. In addition, two armed constables and an SI were sent on the bus to ensure we got to Raipur. We overheard the SI telling the armed constables to “take us down at Dhamtari” but fortunately this plan was abandoned.   We flew out of Raipur the next morning, a day earlier than planned, with no work to show for our time there.

Unless academic freedom, as well as the basic freedom of movement within the country is protected, we will only have one-sided research or probably no genuine research at all. This is not just a problem which the academic community at large should be concerned with, but also all those who have the long term interests of the nation and democracy at heart. One of the major causes for public dissatisfaction with states in the former Soviet bloc was the restrictions they imposed on free thought. The media has already been censored on anything to do with the current Operations in Chhattisgarh; and now it is the turn of the University.

77 Comments → “Police States and Academic Freedom”

  1. lakhsya 6 years ago   Reply

    Nice Article

  2. Exam Buzz 6 years ago   Reply

    Thanks for such a great article

  3. SSC Buzz 6 years ago   Reply

    SSC Zone says thanks a lot of this article.

  4. bihar ka election parinaam

  5. great updates

  6. Great new updates

  7. 5 years ago   Reply

    Himachal and All over India Jobs

  8. Prashant Kishor 5 years ago   Reply

    The author puts the facts on Police States and Academic Freedom. Well done. I can say that the things are far better now in 2016. Thanks

  9. Govt jobs in assam 5 years ago   Reply

    Good writings. Assam Govt Jobs

  10. Recharge Offers 5 years ago   Reply

    Great Post! Get All The Latest Recharge Coupons From India Desire. With Daily Updates Never Miss A Single Deal!

  11. Coupons And Offers 5 years ago   Reply

    Good Article. Visit Here To Get Coupons & Offers

  12. Riya 5 years ago   Reply

    Both Dantewada and Sukma, the police put pressure on lodge owners to deny us accommodation.

  13. sms bomber online 5 years ago   Reply

    Check out our latest text flooder online.

  14. Raj 5 years ago   Reply

    Thanks for your effort and writing this article.

  15. Mortal Kombat XL 5 years ago   Reply

    I just want to say : why you do not click to play!

    - Mortal Kombat XL

  16. Atari Breakout 5 years ago   Reply

    Good blog post. I want to thank you for interesting and helpful information and I like your point of view. Thank you!- I love to read this type of material Good and attractive information I take from it..Thank you for posting such a good article.
    - Atari Breakout

  17. Dragon Ball Z Games 5 years ago   Reply

    Good blog post. I want to thank you for interesting and helpful information and I like your point of view. Thank you!
    - Dragon Ball Z Games

  18. Jabong coupons 5 years ago   Reply

    Independence in research is very important and there should be academic freedom. Condition is really bad in India.

    But I think some restrictions should be there.

    But Simply want to say your article is as amazing. I really like what you guys are up too.
    Thanks for sharing your thoughts

  19. $1 domain name 5 years ago   Reply

    I am glad to see this article. I will get so many information from this article.

  20. Ola Coupons 5 years ago   Reply

    What A Article I Like It And Thanx to Share

  21. Resultsnic 5 years ago   Reply

    cbse Result

  22. Cary Mccaie 5 years ago   Reply

    What’s up! I am similarly a coach. Thank you for setting up such an useful article. Being from NY , has granted me with a excellent know-how on what is needed to walk to Bluff Park. I will continue to come and inspect your website to better grasp where to go once we arrive to gwinnett. Remember to keep blogging and present us your feelings on Waldorf College (IA). Would like to see you soon enough at the new job fair at DuPont. Sayonara.

  23. facebook lite 5 years ago   Reply

    Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don’t really provide anything that I’m interested in, but I’m most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know

  24. gta 5 5 years ago   Reply

    Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don’t really provide anything that I’m interested in, but I’m most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know.

  25. search 5 years ago   Reply

    I was looking for something like this…I found it quiet interesting, hopefully you will keep posting such blogs….Keep sharing.

  26. excel 5 years ago   Reply

    Thanks for all your information, Website is very nice and informative content.

  27. zumbi tsunami 5 years ago   Reply

    For this information, you can aid them greatly.

  28. powerpuff yourself 5 years ago   Reply

    Wow! Thank you! I constantly wanted to write
    on my site something like that. Can I include a fragment of
    your post to my blog?

  29. chinese food near me 5 years ago   Reply

    I really take interest in the information theories.

  30. fishdom 5 years ago   Reply

    Hey there, You have done an incredible job.

  31. 5 years ago   Reply

    I really like your writing style, superb info , appreciate it for
    putting up : D.

  32. stardew valley wiki 5 years ago   Reply

    I like the efforts you have put in this, regards for all the great content.

  33. manny pacquiao 5 years ago   Reply

    Thanks so very much for taking your time to create this very useful and informative site. I have learned a lot from your site.

  34. postcode finders 5 years ago   Reply

    Really happy to have seen your webpage and look forward to so many more entertaining times reading here. Thanks once more for all the details.

  35. wingsio 5 years ago   Reply

    click to play wingsio

  36. Krishna Kumar 5 years ago   Reply

    Thanks for this information. Nice Article..

  37. Danny Kronstrom 5 years ago   Reply

    Great article and subject! Thanks :D It’s an amazing post. Thank you again! It sounds like good. You are gathering lots of different ideas in your blog. Good work my friends. Instead of thinking about what you haven’t written, look at how much you HAVE written :-)

  38. Gay Voyageur 5 years ago   Reply

    Great article. Thanks :)

  39. juegos friv gratis 5 years ago   Reply

    Very good. you are the winner. Do not forget update new information regularly. thank !

  40. 5 years ago   Reply

    Thanks for this marvellous post.

  41. Google 5 years ago   Reply

    Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a couple of unrelated data, nonetheless really worth taking a search, whoa did a single understand about Mid East has got a lot more problerms at the same time.

  42. list of emoticons 5 years ago   Reply

    A great possibility for me and it was a superb knowledge to view this site. Very difficult to uncover these beneficial web page or web site. I have many devices and achieving proper picture of these worked well and energy continues to be seeing about this weblog. Often my own intend to make my personal site as well as my own enjoyment is growing due to this page. I we do hope you may well be more effective.

  43. starnish05 5 years ago   Reply Ohh thats nyc stuff

  44. starnish05 5 years ago   Reply Ohh thats nyc hot stuff

  45. Manali 5 years ago   Reply

    Nice Stuff, I love it.

  46. Bangalore 5 years ago   Reply

    Thanks for sharing this post, Its excellent.

  47. tank trouble 5 years ago   Reply

    I know how it’s an awesome game so I real want to Play it haha :) :)

  48. Goa Jobs 4 years ago   Reply

    Extraordinary article and subject! Much obliged. It’s an astonishing post. Much thanks to you once more! It sounds like great. You are assembling heaps of various thoughts in your blog. Great work my companions.

    • missdelhi 8 months ago   Reply

      Thanks for sharing such a Great Information with us

  49. 4 years ago   Reply

    This is really what we want.

  50. general knowledge 4 years ago   Reply

    thank you for the info

    Current affairs in hindi

  51. fireboy and watergirl 4 4 years ago   Reply

    good job

  52. dumb ways to die 4 years ago   Reply

    it’ okay. that love

  53. Nokia Edge Price 4 years ago   Reply

    Thanks for Sharing Information. Here is the Complete News on jio 4g Mobile 500rs

  54. madalin stunt cars 2 4 years ago   Reply

    I like the efforts you have put in this, regards for all the great content.

  55. AndroidRootingHelp 4 years ago   Reply

    Android Rooting Help is a leading blog to teach all rooting tutorials under one roof. For rooting android follow our blog and tutorials.We love to explore world.AndroidRootingHelp

  56. KiKAPK 4 years ago   Reply

    KiKAPK:KiK APK is one of the best communication app in the universe.KiKAPK

  57. Extraordinary article and subject! Much obliged. It’s an astonishing post. Much thanks to you once more! It sounds like great. You are assembling heaps of various thoughts in your blog. Great work my companions.

  58. online deals 4 years ago   Reply

    nice article

  59. impossible game 2 years ago   Reply

    That’s what police need to care about.

  60. kalika garg 1 year ago   Reply

    Hello, I found this site in search engines. I have browsed most of the posts of this blog, and lots of advice I get. Thank you for sharing.

  61. ShwetaBasu 1 year ago   Reply

    Good Article …

  62. IsaJain 11 months ago   Reply

    You have shared good Articles …

  63. Allia Zen 11 months ago   Reply

    Good Blog…

  64. 10 months ago   Reply

    you have shared good article .. Thanks for sharing !!!

  65. otopark bariyeri 6 months ago   Reply


  66. hot queens 5 months ago   Reply

    Ahmedabad Escorts 24/7 Adult work , Call girls or escort service but also high class. Our selection of premium escorts will offer you erotic massage, fulfill your fantasies

  67. New Flow XL 4 months ago   Reply

    By slowing down how the physique metabolizes these drugs, CBD preserves the treatment’s durability and prolongs its presence within the body. Effectively, CBD can improve and delay the results of drugs that increase the chance of bleeding and the utilization of each concurrently ought to be closely monitored by a medical skilled.

  68. AshikaSoni 2 months ago   Reply

    I am AshikaSoni. you have shared good Article.

  69. HyderabadStars 2 weeks ago   Reply

    Nice Article…

  70. udaipur call girls 1 week ago   Reply

    I’d like to thanks Due to This really Excellent read!! I certainly adored every bit of it. I have you stored as a favorite to analyze things that are new you article…

Leave a Reply